Caso Chevron

Donziger Is Thumbing His Nose At Injunction, Chevron Says

In a memorandum of law filed Oct. 1 but made public Wednesday, Chevron writes that Donziger has raised more than $2.4 million by selling interests in the judgment, with at least $1.5 million ending up in his and his wife’s bank accounts.

Law360 - Mike Curley 26/10/2018

Chevron Corp. has asked a New York federal judge for strong sanctions against attorney Steven Donziger, saying he has been selling interests in a fraudulent $9.5 billion judgment in Ecuador over pollution in the Amazon for his own gain despite court judgments prohibiting him from profiting from the judgment.

In a memorandum of law filed Oct. 1 but made public Wednesday, Chevron writes that Donziger has raised more than $2.4 million by selling interests in the judgment, with at least $1.5 million ending up in his and his wife’s bank accounts.

In doing so, he has willfully and repeatedly violated U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan’s RICO injunction, refused to transfer funds from the judgment to Chevron, and posted online that court decisions against him “deserve no deference by any authority.” The company said in September that Donziger should be jailed for refusing to transfer the funds.

“Donziger’s brazen acts of contempt continue the pattern of racketeering for which he was found liable, threaten the integrity of this court’s rulings and are causing further harm to Chevron,” the company wrote. “Severe sanctions are warranted to secure Donziger’s compliance and compensate Chevron for its injuries because he has shown that he will not comply until compelled to do so.”

Judge Kaplan in 2014 ruled that the $9.5 billion judgment in Ecuador was fraudulently ghostwritten by Donziger and other members of his legal team, who had bribed a judge to sign off on it. An international tribunal ruled similarly in the Hague in August.

Despite the injunction, Chevron wrote that Donziger has sold interests in the judgment to several investors, citing evidence and declarations from his associates that the company said “eviscerates” his claims that he’s raising money for his clients’ legal fees, but instead showing he used the money for his own bills — including $54,000 in American Express charges, a $14,000 gym membership and a $5,000 bar tab — as well as an “out of court” “non-legal” strategy to put pressure on Chevron.

While Donziger has told the court the funds being raised are to pay his legal fees, Chevron wrote that his Ecuadorian clients have told various courts that they cannot afford ongoing court costs and that the agreements to sell the interests are made without their input, and the Amazon Defense Coalition, his remaining client, has no litigation to fund.

Chevron wrote that according to an accounting analysis, since 2016, nearly 95 percent of the funds going into Donziger’s personal and firm accounts came from investors buying interests in the judgment. According to Chevron’s memorandum, he concealed the funding sources by routing transfers through Canadian lawyers.

Finally, Chevron accused Donziger of using shares in the judgment to fund an “extortionate” campaign against Chevron, paying off activists, celebrities and others to create bad press toward Chevron.

These efforts include the upcoming “Indigenous Solutions for Environmental Challenges” conference in Banff, Alberta, for which Chevron said Donziger budgeted $200,000 and will include as speakers many of the activists he paid off with shares from the judgment.

Kathleen Mahoney, who’s organizing the conference, told Law360 that Donziger is not one of the donors, and that the conference is academic and seeks to use the context of the case giving rise to the Ecuador judgment to consider the role of judicial remedies for violations of the rights of indigenous and other affected peoples.

Donziger told Law360 in an email that Chevron’s memorandum was “wholly misleading” and part of a “demonization” campaign, adding he has received “modest fees” for his work in the case. He added that he is preparing a response for the court that he intends to file by Wednesday.

“All expenditures described by Chevron in its motion are personal expenditures made by me after being paid by my clients out of funds they raised for the case with my help,” he said. “They do not violate the terms of the RICO judgment or clarification order. I never raised funds to pay myself; I helped my clients raise funds out of which they paid general expenses for the litigation against Chevron and the accountability campaign used to pressure the company to meet its legal obligations to the people it harmed in Ecuador.”

Donziger said all his work has been to enforce the Ecuador judgment, which he said was affirmed in whole or in part by three appellate courts in Ecuador, and by three layers of appellate courts in Canada, including by the entire supreme courts of both countries.

Donziger further argued that Judge Kaplan’s decision was flawed and based on “paid-for and false” testimony.

Specific to the allegations in the memorandum, Donziger said the figures used by Chevron were “wildly off base,” with a significant chunk of the funds going into his accounts being paid out to attorneys and consultants for the Ecuador case or for another case altogether, while he earns “very little” in fees fighting the Chevron suit.

In a press release issued Thursday, Donziger further accused Chevron of intimidating Katie Sullivan, an associate of his, into signing the affidavit cited by Chevron in its memorandum, saying it was made up of false statements intended to undermine the Ecuador settlement.

According to a transcript of her deposition, Sullivan said she “feared the unknown” that came with the litigation surrounding Donziger and hoped that her part in it would be over quickly so she could get back to her normal life.

She admitted in the deposition that she did not have specific recollection of some actions attributed to Donziger in the affidavit — specifically, assertions that he directed the Amazon Defense Coalition to disburse funds to certain activists, and that he told investors a press campaign would help hold Chevron accountable.

While the draft of the affidavit was prepared by attorneys for Chevron, Sullivan said in the deposition that the affidavit was correct and true, she was able to suggest edits and deletions to put things in her own words — most of which the attorneys incorporated — and that she “put in a lot of effort to make sure that words were not put into my mouth.”

Sean Comey, a spokesperson for Chevron, said all the statements made in the motion are supported by hard evidence.

“All claims from Donziger and his co-conspirators should meet the same standard or be dismissed as what they are — efforts to deflect attention from the overwhelming evidence of his long-running pattern of lawless behavior, which is documented in Judge Kaplan’s exhaustive RICO decision, and affirmed by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals,” he told Law360 in an email. “As described in Chevron’s contempt motion, the evidence shows that this pattern continues to the present day and that Donziger has used his long-running scheme to enrich himself and his supporters.”

Sullivan could not immediately be reached for comment Thursday.

Chevron is represented by Randy M. Mastro, Andrea E. Neuman and William E. Thomson of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP, and Herbert J. Stern and Joel M. Silverstein of Stern Kilcullen & Rufolo LLC.

Donziger is representing himself.

The case is Chevron Corp. v. Donziger et al., case number 1:11-cv-00691, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

--Additional reporting by Caroline Simson. Editing by Adam LoBelia.

 

Fuente Original
  • Últimas Noticias

  • 16/08/19 El Oriente

    Sucumbíos, en paro provincial

    El Oriente

    La Asamblea Provincial de Sucumbíos se reunió esta mañana en el parque de Lago Agrio y decidió iniciar un paro provincial, según un comunicado del Gobierno de Sucumbíos. Las autoridades y la sociedad civil se quejan de la falta de respuesta del Gobierno nacional con las necesidades de la provincia, según el Gobierno sucumbiese.

  • 16/08/19 El Oriente

    Resumen de Noticias El Oriente Ecuador

    El Oriente

    Buenas tardes. Aquí le compartimos lo más reciente.

  • 16/08/19 El Oriente

    Surge nueva oportunidad de producción de energía renovable en Ecuador

    BNAmericas

    El complejo incluirá 25 turbinas y se desarrollará a lo largo de las provincias de Azuay y Loja a 920-1.200 metros sobre el nivel del mar, a unos 84 km de la ciudad de Cuenca.

  • 16/08/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    El corrreísmo perdió la banda de los 4

    4 Pelagatos José Hernández

    Todo estaba previsto. Y todo se cumplió. No hubo entonces sorpresas en el guión del juicio político al cura Tuárez y a los otros tres consejeros del Consejo de Participación Ciudadana y Control Social. Los cuatro fueron censurados. La mayoría parlamentaria funcionó. No hubo cambios en los discursos de los interpelados ni de los interpelantes. Y aquellos que debían acusar recibo de esta destitución también lo hicieron: Rafael Correa y los suyos.

  • 16/08/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Peritos analizarán tintas y antiguedad de los cuadernos de Pamela Martínez

    Expreso Marieta Campaña

    Para despejar las dudas sobre la veracidad de los cuadernos de Pamela Martínez, exasesora del expresidente Rafael Correa, en el caso ‘Sobornos 2012-2016’, la Fiscalía ha dispuesto una pericia. Esta, junto al análisis documentológico se realizará a las tintas utilizadas en la escritura de dichos apuntes.

  • 16/08/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Gobierno anuncia dos refinerías para Esmeraldas

    La Hora

    El consejero presidencial, Santiago Cuesta, anunció ayer que Esmeraldas tendrá dos refinerías. La actual no se va a liquidar, solo concesionar la planta de refinación de crudo.

  • 16/08/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Estado de Excepción carcelaria finaliza con 14 reos muertos

    La Hora

    En las últimas tres semanas no se ha producido ningún episodio violento en las cárceles, afirmó ayer Edmundo Moncayo, director del Servicio Nacional de Atención Integral a Personas Adultas Privadas de la Libertad y Adolescentes Infractores (SNAI). Esto lo dijo al evaluar los 90 días del Estado de Excepción en el sistema penitenciario.

  • 16/08/19 El Oriente

    Prefecto denuncia presuntas irregularidades en la contratación de estudio ambiental

    La Hora

    En la Fiscalía Provincial de Zamora Chinchipe, el prefecto, Cléver Jiménez, presentó una nueva denuncia en contra de la administración anterior. Consiste en un presunto delito de peculado en la contratación de estudios para la obtención de una licencia ambiental; los documentos que argumentan la denuncia fueron presentados para la respectiva investigación.

  • 16/08/19 El Oriente

    Accidente de bus en Archidona deja 4 fallecidos en la vía a Tena

    El Comercio

    Cuatro personas fallecieron en el accidente de un bus registrado a las 23:48 del jueves 15 de agosto del 2019, en el kilómetro 9 de la vía Tena, sector Archidona, provincia de Napo, en la Amazonía de Ecuador. Según el reporte del ECU 911 no se ha podido determinar el número exacto de heridos.

  • 16/08/19 El Oriente

    Omar Tello, el ecuatoriano que sembró su propio bosque para enfrentar la deforestación en Puyo

    El Universo

    Omar Tello tenía 22 años cuando compró una pequeña parcela de tierra de siete hectáreas en su natal Puyo, Pastaza, en 1980. La propiedad que adquirió estaba deforestada.

  • 16/08/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    ¿Ola Bini cae con todo y escaparate?

    4Pelagatos José Hernández

    Ola Bini sabe que su situación cambió. Lo sabe desde el 6 de agosto cuando, en audiencia privada, el fiscal del caso, Fabián Chávez, mostró la forma cómo finalmente lograron ingresar al contenido de su teléfono, que él creía inexpugnable.

  • 15/08/19 El Oriente

    Cuesta habla de reparación, concesión y de nueva planta de refinación en Esmeraldas

    Primicias Wilmer Torres

    La planta estaría ubicada sobre un terreno de 600 hectáreas en Esmeraldas, que la empresa está tratando de adquirir. 

  • 15/08/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Carlos Pareja Yannuzzelli , Álex Bravo y Diego Tapia van a audiencia por caso tráfico de influencias

    El Comercio Sara Ortiz

    Los exdirectivos de Petroecuador Carlos Pareja Yannuzzelli, Álex Bravo y Diego Tapia y otros cinco exfuncionarios de menor rango fueron convocados a la audiencia preparatoria de juicio por el caso tráfico de influencias, para el próximo 29 de agosto a las 09:00.

  • 15/08/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Fiscalía de Ecuador prepara testimonios anticipados en caso ‘Sobornos 2012-2016’

    La Hora

    Nuevas diligencias prepara la Fiscalía dentro del caso ‘Sobornos 2012-2016’, que tiene como procesados al expresidente Rafael Correa, funcionarios de su gobierno y empresarios que contrataron con el Estado durante su mandato.

  • 15/08/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Asamblea revierte su decisión y censura a Verónica Espinosa

    Expreso

    La Asamblea Nacional revirtió este miércoles 14 de agosto su decisión del día anterior de no censurar a la exministra de Salud Verónica Espinosa, en una nueva votación solicitada por una de las asambleístas.

  • 15/08/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    José Tuárez, Rosa Chalá, Walter Gómez y Victoria Desintonio solo duraron 63 días en el CPCCS

    El Universo

    En menos de un minuto, el pleno de la Asamblea Nacional con 84 votos de sus legisladores resolvió la noche de ayer censurar y destituir de sus funciones a cuatro consejeros del Consejo de Participación Ciudadana y Control Social (CPCCS), bajo la causal de incumplimiento de funciones.

  • 15/08/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Vladimiro Álvarez: Cuando empezamos la labor autorizamos levantar el sigilo

    El Universo

    El jurista Vladimiro Álvarez dice que hasta fines de septiembre se implementará la metodología elaborada por el Consejo de la Judicatura (CJ); el Comité de Apoyo a la evaluación de jueces, al que él pertenece, hará un informe con recomendaciones.

  • 15/08/19 El Oriente

    Corporaciones fantasma de China evaden impuestos en el Ecuador

    Diálogo Gustavo Arias Retana

    Corporaciones fantasma chinas utilizan diferentes esquemas para lavar dinero y pagar sobornos por actos de corrupción en América del Sur.

  • 15/08/19 El Oriente

    Condenan a waorani a trabajo comunitario por homicidio

    Ecuavisa

    La justicia ecuatoriana sentenció este miércoles 14 de agosto a 200 horas de trabajo comunitario a un grupo de diez indígenas Waorani que fueron acusados de matar a integrantes de la tribu Taromenane, quienes viven en aislamiento voluntario, y del secuestro de dos niñas en la Amazonía.

  • 15/08/19 El Oriente

    Emergencia en la Amazonía: dos tercios de las especies de la región bajo amenaza por deforestación

    The Telegraph Joe Shute

    Según el informe, si la temperatura global se incrementa al ritmo actual, dos tercios de las especies que existen en la Amazonía estarían en serio peligro dado los cambios climáticos.