Caso Chevron

Scalia/Reid And Chevron: Holiday Reflections On The Rule Of Law

My Torts exams (342 essay answers written by 57 students) are graded. I’m about to head out for a week’s vacation with my wife. (Upon my return I’ve got another batch of exams, from Legal Ethics, to grade before classes begin.) It’s a good time to release pent up frustration about two legal issues currently being bandied about in the press.

Forbes - Michael I. Krauss 15/12/2015

Photo: Forbes

Photo: Forbes

Justice Scalia’s remarks about academic affirmative action are neither racist nor “extreme”

Assume your child was applying to college. If he or she is like my children, he may have “reach” schools, “target” schools and “safe” schools on his or her list. Suppose, however, that he or she receives an offer from a “super-super-reach” school, a school where virtually 100% of matriculants have higher SAT scores (or LSAT scores for law schools, etc.) than him or her. Do you think admission at such a school maximizes your child’s chances of success and of increased self-assurance? If you do, perhaps you don’t realize that SAT (or LSAT) are good predictors of academic success. You are setting your child up for a maximum chance of failure if you plunge him or her into a pool of more highly talented children. Once one realizes the relevance of SAT/LSAT/etc, “go to the best school at which you’re competitive” becomes sage advice to give to one’s child.

There is now sound academic support for this common-sense understanding. Affirmative action (here defined as the admission of academically (LSAT/SAT/GPA, etc.) uncompetitive applicants because of demographic factors unrelated to academic success) by definition creates a mismatch. A 2004 article in the Stanford Law Review conclusively demonstrated that racial affirmative action mismatched law students, leaving black students disproportionately congregated toward the bottom of their classes, both at elite schools and at lower-ranked schools.

How does relative failure affect black students’ self-esteem? How does it affect the perceptions of their non-black classmates? What pressure does black over-representation at the bottom of the class create, as regards grade inflation, “no-grading” policies, “minority studies” majors that minimize inter-racial competition, etc? To reiterate, this relative failure is not the result of racial inferiority, but of racial mismatching resulting from affirmative action. It is not racist to note that students with lower scores, whatever their race, tend to perform more poorly than students with higher scores.

As Columbia linguistics professor John McWhorter recently pointed out, at the University of California San Diego, the year before racial preferences were banned, “exactly one black student out of 3,268 freshmen made honors. A few years later, after students who previously had been “mismatched” to UC Berkeley were attending schools such as UC San Diego, one in five black freshmen were making honors, the same proportion as for whites. UCSD is a good school but not an Ivy school – mismatching higher up the ladder had led UCSD to admit its own cohort of mismatched students.

Reasonable people might disagree, I suppose, about whether such collateral damage is an acceptable price to pay for producing minorities with (barely passing) credentials from better schools than they would otherwise have been admitted to. Reasonable people might perhaps disagree about the constitutionality of such programs. But no one of good faith who has read about the issue can claim, as Senator Reid has just done, that Justice Scalia “endorsed racist ideas” when he wondered whether affirmative action beneficiaries would do better if they were at “slower-track” schools. Like Jack Webb, Justice Scalia was interested in the facts, just the facts, during the Supreme Court hearing. One of those facts is that affirmative action diminishes average black performance.

Ethical Justice that he is, Antonin Scalia has refrained from publicly commenting on Senator Reid’s defamation. Shame on the Senator for his sucker-punch. Mr. Reid, your efforts to bully into silence court members with whom you disagree diminishes the Rule of Law.

Chevron deserves Americans’ support for doggedly fighting off a fraudulent judgment obtained against it in 2011.

I have written about this awful saga before (check out several earlier Forbes postings using links on this page).

To refresh readers’ memories:

1. Texaco was a minority partner with the government of Ecuador in that country’s oil industry from 1964 to 1992. Ecuador received 93% of the joint venture’s profits during the 28 years.

2. At that point it sold its stake to Ecuador, accomplished its share of environmental cleanup of its work, and received a full and total discharge of any liability by the Ecuadorean government, which continued to exploit (and heavily pollute) its site.

3. Nine years later, Chevron took over Texaco. Meanwhile, New York attorney Stephen Donziger had assumed control over a lawsuit on behalf of 30,000 mostly aboriginal residents allegedly damaged by Texaco’s pollution. Obviously this lawsuit had to confront the release obtained by Texaco, that company’s remediation of its work, and Ecuador’s continuing and devastating exploitation of the field.

4. In 2011 an Ecuadorean court condemned Chevron to pay almost $19 billion in damages (an amount later cut in half on appeal). Chevron however had acquired proof that the Ecuadorean judgment had been, literally, purchased by Donziger, and in a civil RICO lawsuit the American corporation prevailed. Well-respected United States District Court Judge Lewis Kaplan concluded that Donziger had bribed, coerced and falsified his way to the Ecuadorean judgment, which had actually been ghost-written for bribed judge Nicolas Zambrano. A judicial colleague of Zambrano corroborated that he and Zambrano had been in the business of selling judgments for thirty years. The Wall Street Journal called the Ecuadorean suit against Texaco/Chevron the “legal fraud of the century,” though it is perhaps rivaled by Volkswagen’s 21at century antics (to be discussed in a column I’ll write in 2016).

Now, though, comes the claim that that judicial colleague of Zambrano, who had produced damning testimony against Ecuador, had himself lied in and been bribed for that testimony. For Chevron is currently suing Ecuador in international arbitration (where I believe Chevron will win many millions). Testifying in that arbitration, Alberto Guerra recently admitted that he had exaggerated the amounts he originally said he had been offered by Donziger, in order to gain the favor of Chevron (which has been paying his living expenses in the United States, in large part in order to ensure his safety). But anyone and everyone who has read Judge Kaplan’s District Court RICO decision knows that Alberto Guerra’s testimony was perhaps 1% of the case against Donziger and Ecuador — and most of Guerra’s testimony (including the receipt of regular sums from Donziger) has not been withdrawn. The evidence of a massive conspiracy against Texaco/Chevron is simply overwhelming.

Hollywood stars may feel good when they drip their hands in Ecuadorean oil (the linked picture is of Mia Farrow in 2014, fully 22 years after Ecuador alone began exploiting the site). Poor Ms. Farrow and her friends should realize that that oil isn’t Chevron’s or Texaco’s. Only after Donziger is sanctioned and Ecuador punished in arbitration will the international rule of law be vindicated.

Michael Krauss is Professor of Law at George Mason University, and a nationally known scholar of Tort Law and Legal Ethics. His home page is here.

Fuente Original
  • Últimas Noticias

  • 24/05/19 El Oriente

    Noticiero El Oriente Ecuador 24-05-19

    El Oriente

    El Chontacuro, obtenido de las palmas de la chonta, no solo es apetecido para curar males respiratorios y otras enfermedades estacionales, sino también lo acompañan – vivos o cocinados – en diversos platos típicos de la selva.

  • 24/05/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    2 años de Gobierno

    El Comercio

    Hace dos años, Lenín Moreno llegó con el correísmo pero decidió distanciarse de él. Y demostró que no se trataba de un tema de estilo o de discurso.

  • 24/05/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Inversión en central Toachi totaliza USD 859 millones

    El Comercio

    Tras dos años y tres meses de que los trabajos en la central hidroeléctrica Toachi-Pilatón se paralizaran, el Gobierno firmó el pasado 23 de mayo de 2019 un nuevo contrato para concluir con las obras pendientes en este megaproyecto energético.

  • 24/05/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Un gobierno de diálogo y lucha contra la corrupción

    El Telégrafo Patricio Carrera

    Ecuador retoma de a poco su identidad pacífica luego de una época autoritaria que intentó imponer un punto de vista y que generó violencia política y corrupción.

  • 24/05/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Moreno viajará a Perú a cita presidencial andina

    Expreso Alfonso Albán

    La cita, que conmemorará los 50 años de la Comunidad Andina (CAN), tendrá como sede el Palacio de Gobierno de Perú.

  • 24/05/19 El Oriente

    Comité de Carchi posterga paro y da nueva pórroga al Gobierno

    El Universo

    El Comité Cívico del Carchi decidió aplazar el paro anunciado para este domingo y  dar un plazo de 30 días para que el Gobierno cumpla con las demandas planteadas. 

  • 24/05/19 Caso Chevron

    La defensa de Ecuador sufre otro revés por Chevron

    Expreso Javier Montenegro

    Para Chevron es un triunfo. Según comunicó la petrolera transnacional este 23 de mayo, la Corte de Justicia de New York multó al abogado Steven Donziger por desacato. El jurista, en 2011, ganó un juicio de 18.000 millones de dólares - que luego se redujo a 9.500 millones de dólares, en contra de la empresa por la contaminación ambiental generada en el Oriente ecuatoriano hasta 1992.

  • 24/05/19 Caso Chevron

    Donziger Held In Contempt In $9.5B Chevron Ecuador Fight

    Law 360

    A New York federal court on Thursday imposed sanctions on suspended attorney Steven Donziger, who helped secure a fraudulent $9.5 billion judgment against Chevron Corp. in Ecuador, saying Donziger had blatantly ignored the court's orders forbidding him from profiting from the award.

  • 23/05/19 Caso Chevron

    Steven Donziger, Disbarred Former Attorney, Is Held in Contempt of Court

    Forbes Michael I. Krauss

    I've detailed the civil contempt of court motion against Steven Donziger in prior columns. So it's very pleasing to read United States District Judge Lewis Kaplan's remarkable, 75-page, contempt of court ruling. It begins with these words: "Steven Donziger, formerly a lawyer, has led a corrupt effort to extort billions of dollars from Chevron Corporation."

  • 23/05/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Comisión quiere llevar a la Fiscalía la investigación del caso Assange

    El Telégrafo

    Julian Assange, al parecer, se mostró como un minucioso conocedor de la historia, geografía y cívica ecuatoriana en su examen para su naturalización.

  • 23/05/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Ecuador y Estados Unidos firman seis acuerdos de cooperación y se compromenten a reunirse anualmente

    El Universo

    Patrimonio cultural, combate al narcotráfico y la delincuencia transnacional, seguridad, educación, infraestructura y préstamos hipotecarios son los acuerdos de cooperación firmados.

  • 23/05/19 El Oriente

    Siete bloques petroleros licitados por 24 años

    Expreso Sebastián Angulo

    Una cuantiosa inversión. Eso espera el Gobierno luego de la licitación de siete bloques petroleros ubicados en la provincia de Sucumbíos a través de la denominada Ronda Intracamos, cuyos contratos fueron firmados ayer.

  • 23/05/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Una política sazonada con tensión y sorpresas

    Expreso

    Los ingredientes de las decisiones en los últimos dos años. Venezuela, Julian Assange, cambios de vicepresidente y otros.

  • 23/05/19 El Oriente

    La Amazonía abre su mundo mágico al turismo

    La Hora

    En este feriado, los ecuatorianos tienen una nueva oportunidad de disfrutar de la naturaleza y las maravillas que se encuentran y descubren en la Amazonía, una zona llena de secretos, misterios, leyendas y, sobre todo, una rica biodiversidad.

  • 23/05/19 El Oriente

    Delimitación física y cartografía de zona intangible del Yasuní estará en 180 días

    El Telégrafo

    A través del Decreto Ejecutivo 751 firmado el martes por el presidente de la República, Lenín Moreno, se incrementa el área protegida del Parque Nacional Yasuní de 758.051 hectáreas a 818.501,42 hectáreas, en favor de los pueblos en aislamiento.

  • 23/05/19 El Oriente

    Avanza la Minería en la Cordillera del Cóndor

    Vistazo Alejandro Pérez

    Dos proyectos están a punto de inaugurar la minería a gran escala sobre la poco explorada Cordillera del Cóndor. Un bosque amazónico único, lleno de especies endémicas y donde habitan comunidades indígenas; mientras su subsuelo oculta miles de millones de dólares en cobre, oro y plata. Minería y gran biodiversidad en un mismo lugar hacen que sea una zona llena de conflictos socio-ambientales.

  • 23/05/19 El Oriente

    Taxista de Puyo devolvió 5.000 dólares a una pasajera

    El Universo

    La acción de un taxista asombró a los habitantes de la ciudad amazónica de Puyo (Pastaza), luego de que buscara afanosamente hasta encontrar a una pasajera que dejó olvidada una mochila que luego se supo contenía 5 mil dólares.

  • 22/05/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Millonario perjuicio al Fisco vinculado a caso 'Arroz Verde'

    El Comercio

    A través de múltiples controles, SRI detectó aproximadamente USD 39 millones correspondientes a impuestos no cancelados por contribuyentes vinculados al caso.

  • 22/05/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    María Alejandra Vicuña va a juicio

    La Hora

    La Fiscalía presentó suficientes elementos de convicción para que la exvicepresidenta María Alejandra Vicuña sea llamada a juicio como presunta autora del delito de concusión.

  • 22/05/19 Ecuador en las Noticias

    Fiscalía investiga agresión a Trujillo

    Expreso

    Mediante un comunicado, la Fiscalía inicia una investigación previa en el caso del expresidente del CPCCS.